writeups

WhiteHat GrandPrix - 100 - Banh Giay - Forensics

noraj (Alexandre ZANNI)
, , ,
🇬🇧

Information#

Version#

By Version Comment
noraj 1.0 Creation

CTF#

Description#

Submit: WhiteHat{SHA1(flag)}

http://material.grandprix.whitehatvn.com/gp2016/For01_7afbfe8847d67c8dd51d7227091bb9aaaafe11f3.zip

http://bakmaterial.grandprix.whitehatvn.com/gp2016/For01_7afbfe8847d67c8dd51d7227091bb9aaaafe11f3.zip

Alternative server on amazon in case of low traffic:

http://54.183.97.137/gp2016/For01_7afbfe8847d67c8dd51d7227091bb9aaaafe11f3.zip

Solution#

  • Download the zip.
  • Extract it.
  • Open the pcapng with Wireshark.
  • Filter http requests.
  • See frame n°134 GET /corporation/secret HTTP/1.1.
  • Extract the file (File > Export Objects > HTTP).
  • Check the type of file:
1
2
3
[noraj@rawsec]–––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––[~/CTF/WhiteHat_GrandPrix/2016]
$ file secret
secret: Zip archive data, at least v2.0 to extract
  • Unzip it:
1
2
3
4
[noraj@rawsec]–––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––[~/CTF/WhiteHat_GrandPrix/2016]
$ unzip secret
Archive:  secret
[secret] EasyExtrack password:
  • Ok, there is a pasword, let's check the html page: frame n°149 GET /corporation/arsenal.html HTTP/1.1.
  • Extract it from the pcapng.
  • See the hint: For H.i.n.t: Referring to arsenal, i remember a number. It also length of secret p.a.s.s.w.o.r.d.
  • One key event is:

30 October: Arsenal recorded victory in the League Cup to a record-breaking 7–5 scoreline at the Madjeski Stadium, having been 4–0 down initially. The game had the most goals ever scored in a single League Cup match (12).

  • With luck and guessing I found this number was 4.
  • So now let's try to crack the zip password with fcrackzip:
1
2
3
4
[noraj@rawsec]–––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––[~/CTF/WhiteHat_GrandPrix/2016]
$ fcrackzip -b -c a -l 4 -u secret

PASSWORD FOUND!!!!: pw == fuzu
  • Extract the zip with the password.
  • Check what file type EasyExtrack is:
1
2
3
[noraj@rawsec]–––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––[~/CTF/WhiteHat_GrandPrix/2016]
$ file EasyExtrack
EasyExtrack: Zip archive data, at least v1.0 to extract
  • Try to unzip it with the same password:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
[noraj@rawsec]–––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––[~/CTF/WhiteHat_GrandPrix/2016]
$ unzip EasyExtrack -d out
Archive:  EasyExtrack
   creating: out/EasyExtrack/
[EasyExtrack] EasyExtrack/flag1.txt password:
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag1.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag10.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag11.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag12.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag13.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag14.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag15.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag16.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag17.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag18.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag19.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag2.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag20.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag21.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag22.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag23.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag24.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag25.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag26.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag27.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag28.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag29.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag3.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag30.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag4.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag5.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag6.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag7.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag8.txt  
  inflating: out/EasyExtrack/flag9.txt
  • Here are all the flags:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
raw: Flag{d2a33790e5bf28b33cdxbf61722a06989}
raw: Flag{12f54a96f6444324693t0da001cafda8b}
raw: Flag{60b725f10c9c85c70d9h7880dfe8191b3}
raw: Flag{f5302386464f953ed58u1edac03556e55}
raw: Flag{d9bed3b7e151f11b8fdyadf75f1db96d9}
raw: Flag{3b5d5c3712955042212n316173ccf37be}
raw: Flag{72cfd272ace172fa3502h6445fbef9b03}
raw: Flag{d2a33790e5bf28b33cdxbf61722a06989}
raw: Flag{d2a33790e5bf28b33cdxbf61722a06989}
raw: Flag{d2a33790e5bf28b33cdxbf61722a06989}
raw: Flag{9a8ad92c50cae39aa2c5604pfd0ab6d8c}
raw: Flag{d2a33790e5bf28b33cdxbf61722a06989}
raw: Flag{d2a33790e5bf28b33cdxbf61722a06989}
raw: Flag{d2a33790e5bf28b33cdxbf61722a06989}
raw: Flag{d2a33790e5bf28b33cdxbf61722a06989}
raw: Flag{d2a33790e5bf28b33cdxbf61722a06989}
raw: Flag{d2a33790e5bf28b33cdxbf61722a06989}
raw: Flag{d2a33790e5bf28b33cdxbf61722a06989}
raw: Flag{d2a33790e5bf28b33cdxbf61722a06989}
raw: Flag{12f54a96f64443s246930da001cafda8b}
raw: Flag{92520a5a9cf8932i20b9cd447f585f144}
raw: Flag{01fbdc44ef819db6p273bc30965a23814}
raw: Flag{9ffbf43126e33be52hcd2bf7e01d627f9}
raw: Flag{12f54a96f644432469o30da001cafda8b}
raw: Flag{9d7bf075372908f55e2nd945c39e0a613}
raw: Flag{92520a5a9cf893220b9cud447f585f144}
raw: Flag{009520053b00386d1173fu3988c55d192}
raw: Flag{e73af36376314c7c0022cbk1d204f76b3}
raw: Flag{e85dde330c34efb0e526ee3j082e4353b}
raw: Flag{7d9d25f71cb8a5aba8620254l0a20d405}
  • Flags are not hashes because they are 33 char long. But we can see there is one non-hex char in each flag.
  • Remove each non-hex flag to get 32 char long MD5 hashed:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989
12f54a96f64443246930da001cafda8b
60b725f10c9c85c70d97880dfe8191b3
f5302386464f953ed581edac03556e55
d9bed3b7e151f11b8fdadf75f1db96d9
3b5d5c3712955042212316173ccf37be
72cfd272ace172fa35026445fbef9b03
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989
9a8ad92c50cae39aa2c5604fd0ab6d8c
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989
12f54a96f64443246930da001cafda8b
92520a5a9cf893220b9cd447f585f144
01fbdc44ef819db6273bc30965a23814
9ffbf43126e33be52cd2bf7e01d627f9
12f54a96f64443246930da001cafda8b
9d7bf075372908f55e2d945c39e0a613
92520a5a9cf893220b9cd447f585f144
009520053b00386d1173f3988c55d192
e73af36376314c7c0022cb1d204f76b3
e85dde330c34efb0e526ee3082e4353b
7d9d25f71cb8a5aba86202540a20d405
  • The extracted wrong letters are (in order): xthuynhxxxpxxxxxxxxsiphonuukjl.
  • Use hashkiller.co.uk to decrypt MD5 hashes:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 MD5 : F
12f54a96f64443246930da001cafda8b MD5 : l
60b725f10c9c85c70d97880dfe8191b3 MD5 : a
f5302386464f953ed581edac03556e55 MD5 : g
d9bed3b7e151f11b8fdadf75f1db96d9 MD5 : {
3b5d5c3712955042212316173ccf37be MD5 : b
72cfd272ace172fa35026445fbef9b03 MD5 : r
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 MD5 : F
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 MD5 : F
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 MD5 : F
9a8ad92c50cae39aa2c5604fd0ab6d8c MD5 : f
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 MD5 : F
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 MD5 : F
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 MD5 : F
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 MD5 : F
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 MD5 : F
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 MD5 : F
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 MD5 : F
d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 MD5 : F
12f54a96f64443246930da001cafda8b MD5 : l
92520a5a9cf893220b9cd447f585f144 MD5 : _
01fbdc44ef819db6273bc30965a23814 MD5 : h
9ffbf43126e33be52cd2bf7e01d627f9 MD5 : e
12f54a96f64443246930da001cafda8b MD5 : l
9d7bf075372908f55e2d945c39e0a613 MD5 : p
92520a5a9cf893220b9cd447f585f144 MD5 : _
009520053b00386d1173f3988c55d192 MD5 : y
e73af36376314c7c0022cb1d204f76b3 MD5 : o
e85dde330c34efb0e526ee3082e4353b MD5 : u
7d9d25f71cb8a5aba86202540a20d405 MD5 : }
  • Unformated flag is: Flag{brFFFfFFFFFFFFl_help_you}.
  • SHA1 the unformated flag:
1
2
3
[noraj@rawsec]–––––––––––––––––––[~/CTF/WhiteHat_GrandPrix/2016/out/EasyExtrack]
$ printf %s 'Flag{brFFFfFFFFFFFFl_help_you}' | sha1sum
e7643ccd180c84176ae0b4361c3b169fceacf961  -
  • Format the flag: WhiteHat{e7643ccd180c84176ae0b4361c3b169fceacf961}.
  • Not the good flag ...

Note that 800618943025315f869e4e1f09471012 is the right md5 hash for F and d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989 is the wrong md5 hash for F that you can obtain with non POSIX tools like echo (that's why I use printf). So only hashkiller knows both wrong and right hash, all other md5 decrypt online tools knows only the right one so they are not able to decrypt d2a33790e5bf28b33cdbf61722a06989. But anyway...

  • You know what? After some wasted hours I figured that I needed to replace F with some guessed letters: Flag{bruteforce_will_help_you}. Yes guessing again.
  • SHA1 the unformated flag:
1
2
3
[noraj@rawsec]–––––––––––––––––––[~/CTF/WhiteHat_GrandPrix/2016/out/EasyExtrack]
$ printf %s 'Flag{bruteforce_will_help_you}' | sha1sum
1e71b26aa01733cd13e5199386c70fe31df43deb  -
  • Format the flag: WhiteHat{1e71b26aa01733cd13e5199386c70fe31df43deb}.
  • Not the good flag ...
  • Description said Submit: WhiteHat{SHA1(flag)}, it depends if flag means Flag{xxx} or xxx.
  • SHA1 the unformated flag:
1
2
3
[noraj@rawsec]–––––––––––––––––––[~/CTF/WhiteHat_GrandPrix/2016/out/EasyExtrack]
$ printf %s 'bruteforce_will_help_you' | sha1sum                                                                    
31bd8aa56447ea1c703d0943e175a06a5c4ee614  -
  • Format the flag: WhiteHat{31bd8aa56447ea1c703d0943e175a06a5c4ee614}.
  • This time this is the good one.

Here was my ruby script:

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
#!/usr/bin/ruby

(1..30).each do |num|
	raw_flag = File.read('flag'+num.to_s+'.txt')
	# Not sanitized flags
	puts 'raw: '.concat(raw_flag)
	only_flag = raw_flag.match(/\{([a-z0-9]{33})\}/).captures[0]
	# Sanitized flags
	puts only_flag.gsub(/[^0-9a-fA-F]/, '')
end

Note: CTF orga team should test challenges and remove the crappy ones before let teams have pain with them.

Submit#

And we also get one of the 23 parts of the puzzle:

This is for the Discovering Vietnam bonus challenge. It is a puzzle of 23 parts, you need them to get a QR-code that give a flag. Flag will give 10% bonus points of the current score.

I think we need to do almost all challenges to get all the pieces.

Share